No sure... would love to know what others think
The first time my cat ate this he threw it up. With all the hype and checking with their customer service, I decided to persevere. I mixed it in with his other food to help the diet change. I also mentioned that he wasn't a fan to his vet. The vet told me Lily's is known to be quite fatty. As its a pate its quite hard to see it but maybe its just too rich for him. I hate the idea of giving him something that's not good for him. If only cats could talk.