Why Is My Cat So Picky? Causes and Feeding Tips for Fussy Cats 

If you are a cat parent, you have likely faced the challenge of your feline friend turning away from food you have carefully chosen. According to Royal Canin, 58% of cat owners offer a variety of foods to encourage eating, while 41% feel anxious when their cats refuse to eat. While it is natural to worry, picky eating is often more about preference and environment than health. Knowing the difference is key to keeping your cat healthy. So, what is behind this behaviour, and how can you keep your cat happy and well fed?  

A kitten trying a variety of safe, high-quality foods to broaden its taste experience.

Offering a variety of high-quality foods early helps kittens accept new flavours and textures and prevents picky eating behaviour.

An advertising feature presented in partnership with Royal Canin. This content is independent of zooplus Magazine’s editorial views. 

The “Why” Behind Fussy Cats

Ever wondered why your cat snubs a perfectly good bowl of food? Just like humans, cats have evolving preferences — especially when it comes to texture, flavour or even the shape of their dry food. It is not just stubbornness: It is an interesting mix of instinct and learned behaviour. 

Recent studies show that over half of cats (53%) are considered picky eaters, with 37% classified as particularly fussy. Additionally, 36% display selective eating behaviours, highlighting the need for tailored nutrition to suit their individual tastes (Fussy Cats & Fussy humans, Mars Petcare & Brand Potential, July 2023) 

As descendants of wild hunters, cats have an exceptional sense of smell and taste, with a natural inclination towards fresh, protein-rich meals. Early experiences also shape their eating habits — limited exposure to different textures and flavours during kittenhood can lead to a fear of new foods, known as neophobia. 

Hydration also plays a role — cats are naturally low-thirst animals, so moisture-rich foods can sometimes be more appealing, especially for those that eat little. So, while your cat may seem fussy, it is a blend of biology, memory and a refined palate at play. 

A fussy cat running excitedly around the room while waiting for its favourite treats. © Royal Canin
Fussy cats need a varied diet. Try different food formats, such as wet and dry food, to find the right flavours and textures.

The Psyche Also Plays a Role in Eating Habits

Overall, cats are sensitive creatures. Stressful changes such as moving house, the arrival of new animals, unfamiliar people or even something as simple as changing the food bowl may affect their appetite. 

Unconscious conditioning also plays a role: If a cat refuses its food and is immediately offered an alternative, it quickly learns that “not eating” leads to a reward. Over time, this behaviour can reinforce fussy eating.  

Lastly, too many treats or table scraps may make regular meals seem less interesting, and frequent changes of food can unsettle a cat instead of helping. 

Other Reasons Behind Picky Eaters

According to International Cat Care (iCatCare), a cat welfare charity that has been working to improve the lives of cats, picky eating can be caused by more than just food preferences. Environmental factors, allergies or other underlying medical conditions may also be involved. 

  • Eating environment: If your cat’s meals are placed in a busy or noisy area, especially near other pets or high foot traffic, it can lead to stress and discomfort, making them less likely to eat.  
  • Food freshness: Cats may refuse food they perceive as stale, rancid or served in a dirty container. Fresh water should always be available nearby. 
  • Medical conditions: Food sensitivities or intolerances may be linked to digestive upset, skin irritation or changes in appetite. These symptoms may also signal more serious issues like Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) — a chronic condition of ongoing intestinal inflammation. Dental pain or kidney or liver problems can also affect appetite, so consult a vet if your cat’s eating habits change suddenly. 

It is important to know: Any sudden or prolonged change in your cat’s eating habits may indicate an underlying health issue. If your cat has not eaten for more than 24 hours or shows symptoms like vomiting, diarrhoea or lethargy, a visit to the vet is essential. Before making any changes to their diet, consult a professional to ensure that it meets their specific nutritional needs. 

Best Tips for Feeding a Picky Eater

Once medical issues are ruled out, there are several strategies to encourage your cat to eat: 

  • Establish a routine: Offer food at consistent times. If uneaten after 30 minutes, remove it and try again at the next scheduled meal. 
  • Adjust food temperature: Cats may prefer food warm, room temperature or cold. Experiment to find what suits your cat best.  
  • Gradual changes in diet: Avoid switching foods abruptly. Introduce new food slowly by mixing it with the old food over 7–10 days. 
  • Explore flavours, textures and toppings: Cats have unique preferences. Some favour specific kibble shapes (round, triangular or X-shaped), while others respond better to wet food textures (like pâté, stew or shredded pieces). Toppers, especially those with strong, appealing scents like fish oil or bone broth, can make a regular meal seem more enticing. 
  • Check their bowls: Cats can be sensitive to smells or textures associated with certain bowls, so try switching the food bowl. For example, from plastic to ceramic or stainless steel.  
  • Make mealtimes fun: Use interactive feeders or puzzle toys to tap into your cat’s natural hunting instincts, making eating more engaging and self-rewarding. Interactive feeding does not just encourage appetite, it also supports mental stimulation and can help reduce boredom-related behaviours, particularly in indoor cats. 

“In a 2024 Royal Canin internal study, 72% of fussy cats showed a preference for specific textures. Royal Canin’s diets are formulated to appeal to both smell and taste, encouraging a positive mealtime experience,” notes Royal Canin

Best Cat Foods for Picky Eaters

Finding the right food means balancing taste, texture and nutrition. You may want to consider different dietary formats, such as chunks in gravy or jelly, or a loaf or pate, to find the right fit for your pet. Look for high protein recipes and rotate between wet and dry formats to keep things interesting. 

With so many options to consider, it can be challenging to find the right routine. That is why Royal Canin has developed new feeding guidelines for both ideal-weight and underweight cats, including mixed feeding recommendations. 

Royal Canin’s Fussy Cats Exigent is developed by nutrition experts to meet the palatability standards of fussy cats. Available in dry format, it can be paired with Royal Canin Sensory or Instinctive wet food. It combines appealing aromas and a crunchy texture to enhance the eating experience. This nutritionally balanced formula offers an irresistible taste experience to cater to the preference of fussy appetites.  

“What’s interesting about Royal Canin Fussy Cats Exigent is that it was validated through extensive research, including a comprehensive Consumer & Market Insights (CMI) study. The results showed high satisfaction rates among pet owners, with 86% declaring that the new Fussy diet answers the fussiness of their cats”.  

Formulated as a complete and balanced diet for adult cats, this food prioritises both taste and health benefits. Still, every cat is unique, so it’s best to check with your veterinarian regularly to ensure that the diet continues to meet your cat’s changing needs. 

“Still, 81% would recommend it after two months. Notably, 28% of surveyed pet owners reported positive behavioural changes, describing their cats as more playful, more active, cuddlier and livelier after switching.” 

Try Mixed Feeding

Many cats also enjoy mixed feeding: a combination of wet and dry food. For this reason, Royal Canin’s Fussy Cats Exigent pairs well with Sensory or Instinctive Wet Food, offering variety in texture and flavour, hydration, and supporting healthy weight maintenance.

It also enables a more customised feeding plan that caters to each cat’s unique tastes and nutritional requirements. 

Important: Be mindful of portion sizes when combining wet and dry food, as overfeeding can lead to weight gain over time. Following your vet’s guidance ensures that your cat stays at a healthy weight. 

Can You Prevent Fussy Eating Habits?

Starting early makes a difference. Offer a variety of safe, high-quality foods during kittenhood to broaden their palate and reduce resistance to new textures or flavours. 

Stick to consistent feeding routines to help regulate appetite. While it is tempting to offer treats or switch foods when your cat refuses a meal, doing so too quickly can reinforce picky behaviour. 

Instead, keep mealtimes structured and introduce changes gradually. Prevention works best when paired with patience — cats can take days or even weeks to accept a new food. Every cat has quirks, but mealtime should not be a struggle. By learning your cat’s preferences, fussy eating can improve.  

A food diary can help you track your cat’s eating habits, symptoms and preferences, which makes it easier to spot patterns and understand their behaviour. 

About Royal Canin  

At Royal Canin, this commitment is no different. Founded by a veterinarian in 1968, the company has always prioritised tailored nutrition based on scientific research and careful observation. With over 50 years of experience in animal nutrition, Royal Canin has dedicated countless hours to studying dogs’ dietary needs to understand how nutrition can support a healthy lifestyle. During the manufacturing process, many different quality controls are implemented and all food production operators follow the same strict protocols. You can explore the full range of products here: Royal Canin Pet Food | Great deals at zooplus!

Find more information about the production process at Royal Canin here: Quality and food safety | Royal Canin UK   

Quellen:

  • Fussy cat attitudinal scale development, CTI & CMI Mars Petcare Brand Potential

For more information on pet food ingredients and legislation, please visit:

Our most helpful articles
5 min

Make your own cat ice cream: 5 great recipe ideas

Summer is the peak season for refreshing ice cream, and cats enjoy it too when it's hot. Would you like to surprise your cat with some ice cream for a change? We will clarify whether ice cream is dangerous for cats and show you how to make your own healthy cat ice cream.