Wouldnt buy them again
Bought a tub of these and the dogs absolutely loved them, but 3/4 of the tub ended up in the bin. They are meaty treats and every time we opened the tub a handful of them looked like they had exploded and turned to a powdery meaty mulch and the smell was horrendous. In the end I didn't want to risk giving them to the dogs. It was summer and although they were stored in a cool place maybe the heat had something to do with it but I wouldn't buy them again.